The Dark Side of Business: Incorporating in Delaware Disadvantages


Written by Peter Keszegh

Delaware – it's the incorporation hotspot, the place where big names flock to set up shop. But hold your horses, aspiring entrepreneurs! Before you jump on the bandwagon, let's talk about the elephant in the room: incorporating in Delaware disadvantages.

I've seen countless companies lured by the siren song of Delaware's incorporation benefits. While those benefits are real, there's a flip side to the coin that often gets overlooked. 

That's where this blog comes in – your guide to exploring the hidden costs and potential pitfalls of incorporating in the First State.  So, grab a cup of coffee, settle in, and let's dive into the dark side of business.

Beyond the hype: incorporating in Delaware disadvantages

Now, let's cut through the hype and take a closer look at those less glamorous aspects of setting up your business entity in Delaware. One of the biggest misconceptions is that incorporating there automatically unlocks a treasure trove of tax benefits. 

Here's the thing: while Delaware doesn't have a corporate income tax on companies incorporated outside the state, you'll still be on the hook for taxes in the state where you actually operate. 

Plus, Delaware itself imposes a franchise tax, a yearly fee based on the number of shares your company has authorized or issued. For small businesses with limited shares, this might not be a huge burden. But as you grow, it can become a significant expense.

Hidden complexities to consider

That's not all – depending on your home state's tax structure, you might even face double taxation. This happens when you're taxed on the same income by both Delaware (through the franchise tax) and your home state. Suddenly, those supposed tax haven dreams start to crumble, don't they?

A businessman walking on the sidewalk

But wait, there's more! Delaware also requires you to have a registered agent in the state, which adds another layer of complexity and cost to the equation. And let's not forget the annual reports you'll need to file, just another administrative task to add to your already overflowing plate.

So, as you can see, the Delaware incorporation story isn't all sunshine and rainbows. Before you swipe your credit card and submit those incorporation papers, it's crucial to weigh the pros and cons carefully.

Cost considerations: beyond the filing fee

Next, let's talk dollars and cents. While Delaware's incorporation process might seem like a bargain at first glance, it's crucial to consider the long-term financial implications. Yes, those initial filing fees might be reasonable, but they're just the tip of the iceberg.

First off, Delaware's fees can actually be higher than other states, especially if your business is on the larger side. So, if you're a small business owner on a tight budget, this could be a significant factor to consider.

What are the other costs?

Even after you've incorporated, the costs don't stop there. Remember that registered agent I mentioned earlier? Well, they don't work for free. You'll need to pay an annual fee to maintain their services. That is even if your business entity doesn't have a physical presence in Delaware. 

It's like paying rent for an empty apartment - not exactly ideal, right? And speaking of legal requirements, Delaware's corporate law can be quite complex. You might find yourself shelling out additional cash for lawyers. 

You also need to pay for professionals to help you navigate the intricacies and ensure you're in compliance. It's not uncommon for these ongoing costs to add up quickly, putting a strain on your financial resources.

A registered agent providing advice to a business owner

The franchise tax

Plus, don't forget about the annual franchise tax, which we discussed earlier. While it might not seem like a major expense at first, it can become a significant burden as your company grows. And if you're operating in another state, you'll also need to factor in those taxes and fees.

So, before you whip out your credit card and hit that "incorporate" button, take a moment to crunch the numbers. While Delaware might seem like a cost-effective option initially, the long-term costs can be much higher than you anticipated.

Considering legal complexities

Alright, fellow entrepreneurs, let's dive into the legal maze that is Delaware's corporate law. You'll need to juggle the legal requirements of both Delaware and your home state. 

This includes the obligation to file annual reports and other necessary documentation, which can lead to confusion, frustration, and even costly mistakes. 

Now, if you're a legal eagle with a knack for deciphering complex statutes, this might not faze you. But for the rest of us mere mortals, it can be a real headache.

Navigating Delaware's legal labyrinth

You see, Delaware has its own unique legal system, separate from the rest of the country. Their corporate law is known for being sophisticated and business-friendly, but it can also be incredibly intricate. 

If you're not familiar with the ins and outs of Delaware's legal landscape, you might find yourself struggling to keep up with the annual reports and other filings required to maintain your business entity in good standing.

And here's the kicker: if your business operates in another state, things get even more complicated. You'll need to juggle the legal requirements of both Delaware and your home state, which can lead to confusion, frustration, and even costly mistakes.

Worm’s eye view of building with business entities inside

Delaware’s corporate laws

To add another layer of complexity, Delaware's corporate laws can be quite specific and nuanced. You might need to seek out specialized legal or accounting services. This is to ensure you're complying with all the regulations and avoiding any potential pitfalls. 

This can translate to additional expenses and time commitments that you might not have anticipated. So, while incorporating in Delaware might seem like a straightforward process, it's important to be aware of the potential legal complexities involved. 

If you're not prepared to tackle the challenges of navigating a separate legal system and potentially seeking out specialized professional services, you might want to reconsider your options.

Location, location, location: when physical presence matters

In the world of business, location can be everything. While incorporating in Delaware might give you bragging rights at cocktail parties, it won't do much to boost your credibility with local customers.

Here's the deal: incorporating in Delaware doesn't magically transport your business entity to the First State. If you're running a brick-and-mortar shop in Texas, for example, your customers won't care that you're technically a Delaware company. In fact, it might even raise eyebrows if they find out you're not a "local" business.

Plus, if your marketing efforts rely heavily on building trust and relationships within your community, incorporating in Delaware could actually work against you. Customers often prefer to support businesses that are invested in their local area, and incorporating elsewhere might signal a lack of commitment to the community.

Prioritizing home state incorporation

Now, if you're running an online business that operates entirely remotely, this might not be a major concern. But for small businesses that rely on local marketing or require a physical presence to serve their customers, incorporating in your home state might be a more strategic move.
A small business owner who works diligently

Think about it this way: if you're running a bakery in Oregon, incorporating in Delaware won't make your croissants taste any better. But having a local presence and building relationships with your customers can definitely give you an edge over the competition.

So, before you get swept away by the Delaware hype, consider the importance of location for your particular business. If you're a local business owner looking to build a strong presence in your community, incorporating in your home state might be a more sensible choice. 

Exploring alternatives: finding the right fit 

Now that we've discussed the incorporating in Delaware disadvantages, let's explore some alternative options that might be a better fit for your business. You're probably wondering, "What are my other options?"

Well, my friend, the good news is that you're not limited to just one choice. In fact, there are plenty of fish in the sea when it comes to incorporation. One option is to incorporate in your home state. 

This can have several advantages, especially for small businesses with a local focus. For starters, you'll be more familiar with the legal landscape and regulations, making compliance a breeze. 

Do you due diligence

Plus, you'll likely save on registered agent fees and other expenses associated with incorporating in a different state. But before you make a decision, do your homework. Research and compare incorporation options in your home state and other states known for their business-friendly regulations. 

Pay close attention to factors like tax benefits, filing fees, legal requirements, and overall ease of compliance. Here are more steps I advise you to take: 

Look beyond the initial filing fees

Some states may have lower initial costs. Still, consider the long-term expenses like annual report fees, franchise taxes, and the cost of maintaining a registered agent.

A small business owner talking to her customer

Don't be swayed by seemingly low filing fees alone. Investigate if there are hidden costs or recurring fees that could impact your budget over time. 

Factor in the cost of maintaining compliance, such as annual report filing fees, potential franchise taxes. Don’t forget to consider the ongoing expense of having a registered agent in the state of incorporation.

Understand the tax implications

Research the tax structure in each state you're considering. Compare corporate income tax rates, franchise taxes, and any potential tax benefits for your specific industry.

Consult with a tax professional or accountant. Get a clear understanding of how incorporating in different states could affect your overall tax burden. 

Consider not only the state taxes but also federal tax implications. Some states might offer more favorable deductions or credits for businesses.

Consider the legal landscape

Familiarize yourself with the corporate laws and regulations in each state. Some states have more complex legal requirements than others. This could mean additional costs for legal counsel and compliance.

Evaluate the level of legal complexity you're comfortable with and factor in the potential need for legal expertise. You should be able to navigate the specific regulations of each state. 

Moreover, look into the state's stance on shareholder rights, corporate governance, and dispute resolution mechanisms. These can significantly impact your business operations.

A pro tip to take note

Don't hesitate to consult with a lawyer or accountant specializing in business law. They can provide invaluable guidance and help you determine the best incorporation option for your specific needs.

When it comes to annual reports, I hate to say but you still need to work on them. Regardless of where you incorporate, you'll likely need to file some form of annual report. The complexity and requirements, however, can vary significantly from state to state.

A male staff of a small business

So, take a deep breath, channel your inner researcher, and start exploring your options. Remember, the goal is to find the perfect match for your business - a state that offers the right balance of benefits, costs, and legal requirements.

The final verdict: weighing the pros and cons 

Well, my fellow entrepreneurs, we've journeyed through the dark side of Delaware incorporation, exploring the hidden costs, legal complexities, and location-based drawbacks. Now, it's time to weigh the pros and cons and make an informed decision about whether Delaware is the right fit for your business.

As we've seen, incorporating in Delaware isn't always the tax haven it's cracked up to be. Sure, there might be some tax benefits for certain types of companies incorporated there, but the reality is that most businesses will still need to pay taxes in their state of operation.

Let's not forget that pesky franchise tax – it might seem small at first, but it can add up over time.

Where to incorporate them?

Moreover, Delaware's legal system can be a labyrinth of complexity, especially for those unfamiliar with its unique corporate laws. Even if you're willing to navigate the legal maze, you might find yourself shelling out extra cash for lawyers and accountants to ensure you're in compliance.

If your business relies on local customers or a physical presence in your community, incorporating in Delaware might not be the best move. I always say that location matters. Incorporating elsewhere won't magically teleport your business to a new state.

A credit card held to be used for a small business transaction

So, before you pull out your credit card and file those incorporation papers, take a step back and consider your options carefully. If you're a small business owner with limited resources and a local focus, incorporating in your home state might be a more practical choice.

I listed below more reasons you should stay home: 

Simplifies your financials

Incorporating in your home state often simplifies financial matters. You'll avoid the added costs of hiring a registered agent in Delaware and potentially reduce your tax burden by avoiding the Delaware franchise tax.

Attracts local customers

By incorporating locally, you align your business structure with your operational base. This demonstrates your commitment to the community and can be a valuable marketing asset for attracting local customers.

Streamlines legal and administrative processes

Moreover, incorporating in your home state can streamline your legal and administrative processes. You'll be working within a familiar legal framework, making compliance easier and potentially reducing the need for expensive legal counsel.

Eliminates complexities in multiple state regulations

This decision also eliminates the complexities of dealing with multiple state regulations. Focus on your home state's requirements to save time and resources, This will help you to concentrate on growing your business rather than navigating bureaucratic hurdles.

Is Delaware still a good option?

Now, don't get me wrong – Delaware incorporation might still be a good option for some businesses, especially large corporations or those seeking venture capital. But it's not a one-size-fits-all solution, and it's essential to weigh the pros and cons based on your specific business needs and goals.

These are the advantages you can enoy by incorporating in Delaware

Robust legal framework

For instance, Delaware's Court of Chancery, specializing in corporate law, offers a predictable and efficient legal environment for resolving disputes. This can be particularly appealing to businesses with complex legal needs or those anticipating potential litigation.

Tax benefits of a small business being applied

Additionally, Delaware's well-developed corporate law framework can be attractive to investors. They often prefer companies incorporated in a jurisdiction known for its robust legal protections.

However, it's crucial to remember that these benefits might not be relevant for all businesses. Small businesses and startups with limited resources and a local focus might find that the costs and complexities of incorporating in Delaware outweigh the potential advantages.

Assess your business

It's essential to assess your business's unique circumstances and priorities before making a decision. Consider your industry, size, financial resources, growth plans, and target market. If you're unsure, consult with a legal or financial professional who can provide personalized guidance based on your specific needs.

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to incorporate in Delaware should be a strategic one, carefully weighing the potential benefits against the drawbacks. Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all answer, and the best choice for your business will depend on your individual circumstances and goals.

The takeaway

There you have it, my friends – the unvarnished truth about incorporating in Delaware disadvantages. While the First State might be a tempting option for some, it's not the perfect fit for every business.

My advice? Don't rush into anything. Take the time to explore all your options, weigh the pros and cons, and make an informed decision that aligns with your specific business goals and budget. 

Keep in mind that incorporating is a big step, and it's crucial to choose a strategy that sets your business up for long-term success.

Read More Articles:

Streamline Your Scheduling with These Alternatives to Doodle Poll

LLC vs PLLC: Which Business Structure is Right for You?